Most Popular White Papers
A hilariously brief history of alternative comedy
Independent on Sunday, The, Aug 5, 2007 by Nicholas Barber
Twenty five years ago
Alternative to ... anyone who tells jokes at working men's clubs while wearing a tuxedo, and then spends the morning playing golf.
What to do: Buy a can of hairspray. Go to the Comedy Store. Release a single. Try not to be racist, but everyone likes a joke about foreigners, and some sexism and homophobia never did any harm.
Who tickled our funny bone: Rowan Atkinson (above), Billy Connolly, Tracey Ullman, Jasper Carrott.
Shows that made us laugh: Not The Nine O'Clock News, Three Of A Kind.
Sample joke: I'm not saying my mother-in-law's fat, but, hey, who bothers to get married these days?
Ben Elton (right) is ... hoping to write sketches for The Two Ronnies, and performing stand-up at The Comedy Store.
Five years ago
Alternative to ... all those laddish, football-supporting blokes from the Nineties.
What to do: Choose the most bizarre, horrifying or miserable subject, and then act it out so naturalistically that viewers might think they were watching a documentary if it weren't so depressing. Go to rehab. Publish a children's book. Don't be racist, sexist or homophobic - just virulently misanthropic.
Who tickled our funny bone: Chris Morris, Armando Iannucci, Simon Pegg (above).
Shows that made us laugh: The League Of Gentlemen, I'm Alan Partridge, The Royle Family, Big Train, The Office.
Sample joke: I'm not saying my mother-in-law's fat, but if she is it's because she's got a genetic disorder called Prader-Willi syndrome. It's actually very serious.
Ben Elton is ... co-writing a musical with Queen and performing stand-up for the Queen.
Twenty years ago
Alternative to ... every second of comedy that predates the 1980s, but Benny Hill and 'The Good Life' in particular.
What to do: Either be a left-wing firebrand, or create a character parodying a left-wing firebrand. Put on a sparkly suit and/ or a pair of Doc Martens. Hang out with miners. Don't be racist, sexist or homophobic.
Who tickled our funny bone: Harry Enfield, Rik Mayall & Adrian Edmondson, French & Saunders, Alexei Sayle (above), Julian Clary
The shows that made us laugh: The Young Ones, Saturday Live, The Comic Strip Presents, Girls On Top
Sample joke: I'm not saying my mother-in-law's fat, because that would objectify her, but she goes around stealing schoolchildren's milk rations, so she probably is.
Ben Elton is ... co-writing exciting sitcoms, and performing exciting stand-up.
Now
Alternative to ... all those gloomy weirdos who don't make it clear where the punchline's supposed to be.
What to do: Lighten up. Doing stuff in character is all very well, but remember you're a entertainer, so there's nothing wrong with silly voices and prosthetic make-up. Publish an autobiography. Be sexist, racist and homophobic, but don't worry, it's all ironic.
Who tickled our funny bone: Little Britain, Russell Brand (above), Ricky Gervais.
The shows that made us laugh: Little Britain, Mock The Week, Peep Show
Sample joke: I'm not saying my mother-in-law's fat, but look at me dressed up as a fat mother-in-law!
Ben Elton is ... writing a sitcom about being a parent, and performing stand-up on ITV while sitting next to a model.
Fifteen years ago
Alternative to ... all the shouting and swearing that went on a few years ago. Alternative is the new mainstream, so it's about time you smartened up and reminded everyone how well-educated you are.
What to do: Get your own sketch show/ sitcom/panel game/talk show/ all of the above. Go to the Groucho Club. Write a novel.
Who tickled our funny bone: Clive Anderson, Vic Reeves (above), Rob Newman. Plus all those from five years ago.
Shows that made us laugh: A Bit Of Fry & Laurie, Have I Got News For You, Whose Line Is It Anyway, Mary Whitehouse Experience
Sample joke: I'm not saying my mother-in-law's fat, but I'm going to improvise a monologue, in the style of Dylan Thomas.
Ben Elton is ... writing environmentalist novels and West End plays, and his own BBC stand-up series.
The future
Alternative to ... Who can tell?
What to do: Film your own montage of stand-up, sketches and animation, and then post it on MySpace. Go to a club you've set up yourself. Hang out with your Facebook friends online. Publish a blog.
Who will tickle our funny bone: Mark Watson, Josie Long (above), Tim Key.
The shows that might make us laugh: TV? TV is so 2007! Switch onto YouTube and comedybox instead.
Sample joke: I'm not saying my mother-in-law's fat, but here she is saying she's fat herself, live via the webcam.
Ben Elton is ... writing a sitcom about how tricky teenaged daughters are, and perfecting "kneel-down comedy" as he accepts a knighthood.
Ten years ago
Alternative to ... all those earnest Old Labour clever-clogs from the Eighties.
What to do: Forget about a little bit of politics - everyone knows the Tories are on their way out. Do some observational gags about sharing a flat with a lager lout. Go to the pub. Hang out with Britpop bands. Be sexist, but only ironically.