How Hitler reached the final solution

"... The Nazis were fantasizing--basically planning to redesign the demographic map of Eastern Europe by moving all sorts of populations from here to there and eliminating those they thought superflous...."

AMONG ALL THE HORRORS of human history, almost nothing rivals the "Final Solution." Nazi Germany's attempt to rid Europe of Jews; first by expelling them and then, when that tailed to work fast enough, by murdering them--men, women, and children of all ages How human beings could do such a thing to others staggers the imagination and will be discussed and agonized over forever, not merely by Jews, but anyone with a heart and conscience.

Although much is known about the Holocaust from eyewitness accounts, research, books, movies, and the news media, a lot more remains to be explored. Part of that exploration is uncovered in The Origins of the Final Solution: The Evolution of Nazi Jewish Policy, September 1939-March 1942 by Christopher R. Browning, Frank Porter Graham professor of history at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.

Browning has made a career of studying modern German history, and Nazism in particular. At present, he is studying Jewish factory slave labor camps in Starachowice in central Poland for another book. His previous works include Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland; Collected Memories: Holocaust History and Postwar Testimony: The Path to Genocide; Nazi Policy Jewish Labor; German Killers: Fateful Months: Essays on the Emergence of the Final Solution: and The Final Solution and the German Foreign Office.

He says he undertook his latest book two decades ago as a cornerstone of a more than 20-volume comprehensive history of the Holocaust, a project sponsored by Yad Vashemm, the Israeli Holocaust memorial, museum, and research center Most other participating authors are Israeli scholars working on national Jewish communities throughout Europe.

"When we started, no one knew, of course, that the communist regimes of Eastern Europe were about to collapse and that all sorts of closed archives, suddenly would come open to us," Browning recalls. "Although I basically finished my work in 1989, I had to rewrite it extensively because of the great windfall of documents. There were "all sorts of new things to investigate."

Commentators already are describing the book as having an "unusually incisive writing style" and as being extraordinary" and a masterpiece of the historian's art," Paul Royster, director of the University of Nebraska Press, calls it "the most important book on European history being published anywhere in the world this year." In an Atlantic Monthly review, Benjamin Schwartz writes, "Browning has obviously mastered every pertinent document available from archives in Germany, the United States, the former Soviet Union and Israel and assimilated them all into his sometimes day-by-day account of the development of Nazi policy."

The UNC historian presents a detailed picture of how Nazi policy evolved during the victorious euphoria of the first 30 months of the war. During that period, the idea that the regime could solve "the Jewish question" by ethnic "cleansing," or expulsion, degenerated further into one in which the perpetrators "harnessed the entire apparatus of a modern nation-state to solve their serf-imposed racial problem" through mass murder. "That seemed to me a very key question in the history of the Holocaust--how they made those last steps.... I argue that the Nazis were fantasizing--basically planning to redesign the demographic map of Eastern Europe by moving all sorts of populations from here to there and eliminating those they thought superfluous ... Slave, Jew, and gypsy. But it really was out of what I call the corruption of racial imperialism that they developed the capacity to imagine the genocide and the personnel geared and eager to do it, and thus could unleash the final solution, beginning in the summer and fall of 1941."

How the Nazis' nightmarish designs were carried out was far more complicated than just following Fascist dictator Adolf Hitler's orders, which often were intentionally vague, Browning explains. "What you had was a very complex interaction between local authorities on the one hand and the central government and littler on the other: Certainly Hitler's obsession with the Jewish question created a situation in which all who wanted to please Hitler, who believed in and were devoted to him and wanted to be rewarded with more power, were anxious to be seen as solving it."

In the beginning, no one appeared to know what that was going to mean, and such "solutions" as shipping all European Jews to Madagascar seriously were considered. After 1941, it meant murdering every last Jew--man, woman, and child--the Nazis could lay their hands on.

"In all of this, Hitler represented what I call an ideological imperative--he legitimized the necessity for finding a solution, but he did very little in terms of hands-on policymaking," Browning contends, "Various people came to him with various proposals, and he gave them the red light or the yellow light or the green light, but it certainly wasn't a matter of orders from above and coercion. People vied with one another very competitively to get credit for being the ones offering the most radical solutions to solving the Jewish question. Hitler was, in a sense, at the switch, deriding which proposals to approve and who to give more power to and who to reward for what they had done before."